Thursday, August 27, 2009

Academics meet to discuss Tenth Malaysia Plan



KITA-UKM hosted its first focus group discussion session among academics on August 27, 2009 (Thursday) at 10am to 1pm at the KITA-UKM Conference Room. This was attended by Prof Dr Ragayah Hj Mat Zain (IKMAS), Prof Mansor Mohd Noor, Dr Vijei, Mr AnisYusal, Dr Kamal Sadiq and Datuk Dr Denison Jayasooria

In this first gathering Prof Ragayah and Prof Mansor presented their findings from their earlier research by extracting key data, implications and recommendations which have relevance for the minority communities in general and for Malaysian Indian community in particular.

Other UKM academics who have agreed to be part of this academic focus group are Prof Chamhuri Siwar (Lestari) and Prof Dato Dr Abdul Raham Embong (IKMAS). They will be presenting their papers at the next gathering.

One major exercise being undertaken by the KITA-UKM team is how do to formulate a development framework which is more inclusive for the bottom 40% of our community especially among the low income groups where relative poverty is the central issue.

Much of poverty focus has been upon the hardcore poor using the poverty line index (PLI). With rural-urban migration how should public policy makers formulate programmes and provisions to address socio economic inequalities among low income families in the urban poor locations.

Prof Ragayah in her presentation made references to the visibility and concentration of low income Indian families in certain urban locations. This must be address by greater access and social inclusion initiatives.

Prof Ragayah also showed through her analysis of data that the issue is not some much inter ethnic income inequalities but intra ethnic inequalities. This aspect of income inequalities within the community is being missed by politicians who continue to focus on race based arguments, when the data is now showing the issues are about socio-economic class and gender which are cutting across all the ethnic groups.

Prof Manor’s inter ethnic studies also shows the struggles of the bottom 40% of Malaysian society who are currently unhappy with delivery concerns. The concerns expressed cuts across all the racial and ethnic groups especially in urban poor locations. He also notes that public policy and policy makers are not giving adequate attention to this dimension.

In the course of the discussion it was pointed out that the civil service must become more sensitive and more responsive to the low income families irrespective of ethnic origins or gender differences. In addition often people are also discriminated based on political affiliations at the grassroots. This too must be avoided in order to ensure that access and equitable opportunities is made available to all Malaysians.

Community leaders providing input


The Deputy Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department, YB Dato S.K.Devamany with the assistance of KITA-UKM hosted five Working Groups to receive input pertaining to Malaysian Indians. These were held from August 24 to 26, 2009 at the office of Deputy Minister in Putrajaya

The five areas were:

Poverty & Social Issues (August 24 from 10am to 1pm)
Civil service Recruitment & Promotions (August 24 from 2pm to 5pm)
Economic, business & entrepreneurial development (August 25 from 10am to 1pm)
Education/ Training & Human Capital Development(August 25 from 2 to 5pm)
Effective delivery & implementation (August 26 from from 10am to 1pm)

Each of the working groups had between 17 to 26 people from a cross section of the community including a number of EPU staff. There was a strong participatory dimension to the discussions and all had an opportunity to make the comments and recommendations.

A simple framework which guided the discussion was based on three key points:-
We have also indentified a three- fold framework for analysis:

Review the policies & provisions in the Ninth Malaysia Plan
Analyse the effectiveness, noting achievements & challenges
Chart recommendations for the Tenth Malaysia Plan

These discussions were facilitated by Datuk Dr Denison Jayasooria at the same time all present make some important contributions. Mr Victor Joseph was busy with his note book undertaking a basic record of all the exchange of ideas.

A report of the working group’s findings will be finalized by this weekend and made available to all the participants.

Consultancy Study Project on Tenth Malaysia Plan & Malaysian Indians



CONSULTANCY PARTNERSHIP

The consultancy study project is commissioned by the Yayasan Strategik Sosial to the Institute of Ethnic Studies (KITA), Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia.

Datuk Dr Denison Jayasooria (Principal Research Fellow) is the lead consultant however, a number of other KITA fellows will serve as resource persons providing multi disciplinary and multi racial perspective.


TERMS OF REFERENCE

To undertake a study of the issues and concerns of the Malaysian Indian community noting the grievances of the community on the one hand and achievements on the other

To review the Third Outline Perspective Plan, the Eighth and Ninth Malaysia Plans noting the provisions and implementation, achievements and success, gaps and shortcomings

To chart out a framework for socio-economic development with specific provisions, programmes and implementation strategies for Tenth Malaysia Plan

To develop specific recommendations on effective public sector delivery in partnership with community support during the Tenth Malaysia Plan period



SCOPE OF STUDY

This study will focus attention on the Malaysian Indian community during the Ninth Malaysia Plan period (2006-2010) and compare the achievements and shortcomings alongside other minority and disadvantaged communities.

In reviewing this period the study will also chart out the directions for the Indian community in line with contemporary national policies such as One Malaysia, economic liberalisation, meritocracy and competition along with the dynamic notion of globalization.


OUTPUT

A policy document which be presented to the Prime Minister and the Economic Planning Unit as input into the Tenth Malaysia Plan



METHODOLOGY

Literature Review:
To undertake a comprehensive review of contemporary Malaysian Indian issues including a critical analysis of the various development plans and reports

Focus Group Discussions:

To organise community leaders for critical assessment and formulation of recommendations for policy input.

To organise focus group discussions with those who (multi disciplinary and multi ethnic team) have the expertise and experience.

To identify resource persons/ subject experts to write position papers on identified topics which can provide the analysis and depth required in writing the strategy papers

Preparing the Strategic Document: To write the consolidated report with specific recommendations, programmes and implementation strategies.


TIME FRAME:

Three to six months (Between August and January 2010)